Would you rather line up for cupcakes or Manolo Blahniks?

That's not exactly the question posed by Food Gal, but still, she brings up a good point about some of the lines that form at bakeries. I was outside the Bleecker Street Magnolia Bakery (btw, they're hiring!) and even on a drizzly Saturday afternoon, there were plenty of people. But the heart of her review focuses on Kara's Cupcakes, which now has outposts in San Francisco and Palo Alto. These are from the new Palo Alto one:

Kara's Cupcakes

Not having the time or patience on that particular day, I headed to Kara’s instead. And I walked right in. No line. But plenty of cute cupcakes. I chose a banana cupcake with cream cheese frosting, a “Java” (chocolate cupcake with espresso buttercream), and a Fleur de Sel (chocolate cupcake filled with caramel, then topped with ganache frosting and a sprinkle of sea salt). My tab? Just under $10. Gulp.

This was my first taste of Kara’s cupcakes. I had high hopes after Cooking with The Single Guy raved about the ones at the San Francisco branches.

The banana one was homey, old-fashioned comfort with a smear of thick, sugary sweet frosting. The coffee buttercream was like silk. And the Fleur de Sel? Like a gourmet Hostess cupcake for the 21st century — ultra rich, moist, adult, and absolutely decadent.

Though I have tried the cupcakes at Sprinkles in Beverly Hills, it was years ago. So it wouldn’t be fair for me to make a side-by-side comparison from memory. But I will say this: Based on how sublime Kara’s cupcakes are, Sprinkles has a high bar to hit.

Comments

mmmmmmm...thanks for sharing. and tasting. my dream job would certainly be an official cupcake taste tester.
Anonymous said…
Just the way I like my cupcakes. Simply decorated with just a swirl of icing. As much as I like looking at novelty designs, the actual eating of one must be done on a traditional looking one. Classy, simple and indulgent.